|
Marriage by Mail: The Internet makes it easier for
potential mates to connect across seas
By Joyce Nishioka
AsiaWeek July 29, 1999
Roy Des Ruisseaux admits
that he had no luck with women. Nine years ago, at age 49,
he found himself never-married and lonely, despite what he
describes as a lifelong dream of settling down.
“I was the kind of guy who met someone I liked and would
get too anxious, or I would focus on someone not right for
me,” said the New England postal carrier. “I can look back
on it now and laugh.”
That’s because Des Ruisseaux, of Upper Dardy, Penn., has
been happily married for some six years to “the one” -- a
Filipina whom he met through Sunshine International, an
introduction service that links up American men with
foreign women.
De Ruisseaux remembers when he first gave serious thought
to using a service. One weekend some nine years ago, he
was resting in a tent after completing a car race. He
recalls thinking, “This is not what I want. Judging by the
way I am, I’m not going to meet anyone.”
He had heard the stereotype that men who used “pen-pal”
services “don’t date and are real losers,” but he thought:
“Who cares -- if it works. I had no problem with wanting
to get married.”
Des Ruisseaux said he sent off about six letters to women
featured in the services’ catalogs, to which no one
responded. Better results came after he paid $125 to have
his name posted in four catalogs. Soon he began receiving
letters, including one from Josie, then a 38-year-old
living in the Philippines.
“She asked a lot of questions,” Des Ruisseaux recalls. “It
sounds goofy, but questions like: ‘if you were on a
deserted island, if you could meet one person in history
...”
He thought: “That’s me. I can write pages about that
stuff.”
After corresponding for about a year, Des Ruisseaux
traveled to Hong Kong, where Josie worked as a maid.
Though her parents had long urged her to settle down,
Josie, too, had never wed. “I didn’t meet the right guy,”
she explained.
Recalling her first impression of her husband, Josie De
Ruisseaux hesitates for a moment before replying. “He was
OK,” she says during a phone interview, laughing as her
husband chuckles in the background. “I don’t know why I
chose him. I liked his name.”
She notes that she was skeptical at first, asking him how
many other girls he was planning to meet on his trip. “I
heard about other men who say they’re going to meet three
ladies in Manila and pick out the best one,” said Des
Ruisseaux. “No. To me that doesn’t make sense. I told her
she was the only one here to see.”
Another year passed before Des Ruisseaux brought his
fiancee to the United States in March 1993, during which,
Josie says, her friends and family told her she was
“crazy.”
She recalled thinking, “Let’s see what happens. I can
always come back if it doesn’t work out.”
“She packed her bags, quit her job, then flew almost 9,000
miles away with the understanding that we’re getting
married,” says De Ruisseaux, explaining his wife’s
anxiety.
She wanted to get married almost as soon as her plane
landed, he says. They did, some three weeks later. Today,
Josie De Ruisseaux works as a seamstress, but has not
applied for citizenship yet.
“I admire my wife to have the courage,” says her husband.
“What did I do? I got married, but I live in the same
house, have the same job. She moved in with a guy she
barely knew.”
STATISTICS
An INS study, “The Mail-Order Bride Industry and its
Impact on U.S. Immigration,” estimates that 100,000 to
150,000 women, including American women, advertise
themselves for marriage through e-mail or other
correspondence services.
The study, released this year, estimated that some 5,000
Filipinas come to the United States through mail-order
bride services each year; just as many come from Russia,
the other country leading the list. They are commonly
recruited through local newspapers, women’s magazines and
word of mouth. The study notes, however, that only about 1
in 5,000 marriages in the United States has its roots in
overseas introduction services.
In the past five years, the Internet has fueled the boom.
Though international correspondence services like the one
Roy De Ruisseaux used have been around for well over 20
years, more men are logging in to sites like “Foreign
Brides International” and “Asian Brides by Mail” to find
their mates.
The “growth of [international Internet dating] services
has been phenomenal.” noted the INS study, which cited the
growth of goodwife.com, a so-called clearinghouse to
introduction sites. As of mid-March 1998, it says, the
site had 153 Web listings. Two months later, there were
202. By this spring, it had more than 340 listings,
including 89 Asian sites and 168 Russian ones.
Traditional letter-writing services, however, remain
popular -- a fact that the study explained by noting that
many women searching for husbands are also looking for a
means to escape poverty and have no access to computers.
The ones who use online matchmaking services tend to be
older, better educated, and more likely to live in a
relatively developed country such as Japan or Russia,
according to the INS report.
THINGS CAN WORK OUT
Cecilia Julag-ay, a professor at California State
University-San Bernardino, is one of the few experts on
mail-order bride companies -- or international
correspondence services, as she and other supporters
prefer to call it. ” ‘Mail-order bride’ is pejorative,” she
explains. “It doesn’t do justice to the couples having
very nice marriages.”
For her doctoral dissertation, Julag-ay, of Filipino and
European descent, interviewed 40 people who had entered
into correspondence marriages. “The vast majority were
more or less along the lines as any other marriage,” she
said.
Of the subjects, a third had been married to each other at
least 20 years, usually in “good, stable marriages.”
Another third, she said, had been married between three
and nine years with “everything needed to have long-term
marriages.”
She did concede, though, that unions among the other third
“had definite exploitation of one spouse or the other.”
Julag-ay looked only at marriages in which the wife was
from the Philippines, where the practice is more common
than in any other Asian country. One reason for that, she
explained, stems from U.S. colonization and
neo-colonization of the Philippines.
“A lot of Filipino women are familiar with the English
language and American culture and find it easier to take
on U.S. norms” than do other Asian women, observed the
scholar. Given widespread poverty and the fact that
matchmaker-arranged marriages are already entrenched,
especially in rural areas, the thought of meeting a mate
through the mail, or e-mail, is worth considering.
“A lot of people need to help families in whatever way
possible,” Julag-ay said. “By tradition, the eldest in the
family is responsible for taking care of parents and
younger siblings. A lot of times the eldest daughter will
seek a marriage outside the Philippines to help the
family,” possibly by sponsoring relatives for citizenship
down the line or by sending financial help, she said.
“Once you’ve left, you do have an obligation to send money
back.”
“In the United States, there is higher expectation to find
someone ourselves, fall madly in love and that’s going to
be our marriage.” But in the Philippines, she said, “the
idea of going through a correspondence service really
isn’t out of line.”
IT’S NOT FOR EVERYONE
Without doubt, though, there are a lot of “ifs.” For one
thing, while some services are legitimate, others may not
be. “Asian Lovers & Mail-Order Brides,” for example,
features women who all look like models and invites
visitors to order literature like “The Fantasy Islands
Guide to World Sex” and “Adult Travel and Mail Order
Brides” -- just a mouse click away.
Abuse is another problem. The INS study notes that though
the agency has no statistics on how often such wives are
abused, “there is every reason to believe that the
incidence is higher in this population than for the nation
as a whole.”
The potential for conflict rises, it said, with every year
that the women assimilate into American culture.
“Authorities agree that abuse in these marriages can be
expected based on the men’s desire for a submissive wife
and the women’s desire for a better life.”
Becky Masaki, executive director of the Asian Women’s
Shelter, agreed that women in such arrangements do face a
greater risk of abuse. Though any kind of relationship
could potentially lead to domestic violence, she cautioned
that the risks are greater in an Internet or pen-pal
relationship.
“The danger is not being able to fully know the person
while you’re dating,” she explained. “Through e-mail,
people who are abusive can disguise themselves. They can
put forth a different persona.”
Over the past year and a half, Masaki said, the shelter
has seen clients who met their husbands through the
Internet. “I know of women who have escaped abusive
situations who met their partners through e-mail,” she
said. “Language is a big part of it. There is a potential
for miscommunication.”
Masaki, who also refrains from referring to the women as
“mail-order brides,” stresses that those she has met have
not been gold-diggers. They “entered in the relationship
in good faith. They didn’t enter the relationship just to
come here.”
Abuse, in fact, is the one exception to the INS
requirement that a spouse remain married to her American
sponsor for years.
While men and women can divorce and then self-petition for
citizenship as an abused spouse, proving a case is not
easy. Someone seeking such an exemption should have her
claim well-documented with police reports, notes from
medical exams, photos and other information, said INS
spokeswoman Sharon Rummery.
Still, some women’s advocates maintain that men who
support the introductions industry are also perpetrating
abuse. Dorchen Leidholdt, director of the Center for
Battered Women Legal Services in New York City and
co-executive director of the Coalition Against Trafficking
Women, said “This is a big international business that is
about affluent, white Western men who want submissive
women to meet their sexual and domestic needs, complicated
with the fact that the women are often impoverished and
entertain notions that Western men are nice and better
than men from their own country.”
“The women are Asian, African and Latin American and the
men are Caucasian, with a white-man’s fantasy of who these
women are.”
“People are reaping profits by playing to the fantasies of
the men,” said Leidholdt. “The women will not demand equal
treatment. They will stay in the home and do what you want
-- that’s the clear message.”
Several mail-order marriages gone wrong have, in fact,
made headlines in recent years. Susana Remerata Blackwell,
a Filipina, met her husband, Timothy Craig Blackwell,
through a mail-order service but left him 10 days after
arriving to the United States in 1994, alleging abuse.
During divorce proceedings a year later, Blackwell, a
47-year-old computer technician, accused her of tricking
him into marriage, and then shot and killed her and two of
her friends, according to news reports. He was sentenced
to life without parole.
Then there’s Terry Nichols, who went to the Philippines in
1989 to meet women who had responded to his newspaper ads.
He was introduced to Marife Torres, a high schooler from a
poor family. They got married just after she graduated,
but soon after she came to the United States, her mother
said Torres complained she had to work “like a maid.”
Nichols today is behind bars in the Oklahoma City bombing.
“They have the money; they control the women’s immigration
sponsorship,” Leidholdt said. “The women have to do what
the men want or get out or get beaten.”
The activist, who has worked with the Women’s Crisis
Center in the Philippines, said that many women end up
going back to their country of origin.
“It’s another side of the story that rarely gets any
public attention,” said Leidholdt, who estimates that her
organization has represented around a dozen mail-order and
Internet brides.
Even though President Corazon Aquino in 1990 signed a
measure banning the production or distribution of material
promoting the solicitation of Filipinas for marriage to
foreigners, and even though the law says violators can be
sentenced to up to eight years behind bars, it is
difficult to enforce, given the number of firms outside
the Philippines -- and the ubiquity of the Internet.
Leidholdt notes that firms still offer that service as
well as “sex-tours” arranged for the benefit of mostly
white Westerners.
To Leidholdt, though, the bottom line is clear. “This is
all about inequality. The men hold all the cards.”
THE GREEN-CARD TRACK
The INS study, though, indicates that the appeal of living
in America is a significant factor for many brides and
brides-to-be, even though it takes at least four and a
half years for a overseas bride to become a citizen and
often takes twice as much time or more.
“If someone lives overseas, once they marry an American,
they are immediately eligible to immigrate here legally,”
Rummery said. “If they are here already, they are
immediately eligible to file to adjust their status to
become lawful permanent residents.”
In 1996, 7,317 men and women petitioned for “fiancee
visas,” including 3,468 from Asian countries and 1,274
from the Philippines alone, according to Rummery. Though
she said the agency did not have a breakdown of where they
were in the naturalization process, she did note that the
INS usually holds so-called “bona fide marriage
interviews” with one or both spouses only if there is a
“good reason to question the marriage.”
The process begins when a spouse-to-be is issued the
“fiancee visa,” a K-1 visa good for 90 days in which the
applicant expects to be married. After the marriage, the
new spouse, now classified as a “non-immigrant,” can
continue her stay by petitioning to have her status
redefined as a “lawful permanent resident,” a process that
Rummery said takes 18 months.
After receiving permanent status, the spouse can petition
for a two-year conditional green card, after which time
she may apply for citizenship. However, as with the
previous steps, the spouse must in most cases remain
married to her American sponsor and must be “residing in
marital union,” as Rummery said the government puts it.
After two years, the spouse apply for a regular green
card, which would allow her to apply for citizenship even
if divorced.
Citizenship itself takes at least one year to process. For
most applicants, gaining it requires successfully
completing interviews and tests to assess good moral
character, comprehension of English and knowledge of
American civics and history.
“The idea is to make yourself into something you weren’t
before, something new -- an American,” Rummery said.
Imperfect PERCEPTIONS
The INS study found that a top priority among would-be
brides is the chance for a better, more affluent life with
a man more likely to be faithful and nonabusive than a
native-born spouse. It also found that women of Asian
descent were markedly younger than their European
counterparts, the study found: 61 percent of the Asian
women were under 25, whereas only 31 percent of the
Russian women advertised were under 25.
“Often there is an enormous age difference that
exacerbates the inequality,” Leidholdt said. “Many times
these men can’t make it with women in this country.
Sometimes they are socially inept or just jerks.”
She added that the fact these men are unable to have equal
relationships may indicate “they have serious problems.”
The INS report said that the men, a large majority of whom
are white, wanted a wife with “traditional values.”
American women are “thought to be more concerned with
their own careers than being a wife, while Asian women are
perceived to be content as homemakers.”
Though Julag-ay found that the men who sought Asian brides
were “along the lines to what the popular media has
presented - ultra conservative, basically not all that
emotionally stable,” she adds, “that isn’t the full
truth.”
Valuing traditional things in life means the men “tended
to want a lifestyle in which they wanted to be the primary
breadwinner,” she said. In many cases, she said, “it was a
good fit with the social expectations of the women.”
DEFENDING BUSINESS
Cherry Blossoms, based in Hawaii, was founded 25 years
ago. Today, it lists over 6,000 women at any one time.
Half are Filipinas; Indonesians rank next. The biggest
increase, however, has been in Eastern European women
looking for love American style, says the owner, Mike
Krosky, who bought the business five years ago.
“It is not a mail-order bride service, it is an
international personal ad service,” says Krosky, who
estimates that his company’s services result in over 1,000
client marriages per year.
“There are a lot of things I could do to improve profits,
I could only publish drop-dead gorgeous, best educated and
make more money,” he says. “But I’m trying to help people
meet for love and marriage on their own values. We put out
a great variety of looks and professions.”
Cherry Blossoms has recently put up a Web site, but Krosky
says most of his business is still out of his print
catalogs. Addresses cost $10 each or $395 for a one-year
subscription, and women can advertise for free. Some 6,000
do each year, says Krosky; about 2,000 to 3,000 men use
the service every year.
Though most of the women featured are in their 20s or 30s,
Cherry Blossoms has been “getting more older, attractive
women in their 30s and 40s,” Krosky says. He hopes to
expand into publishing ads toward women who want overseas
mates, he said.
“Women from all over the world are given greater
opportunity to find men through letter writing than going
outside their country,” says Krosky, who challenges
contentions that his industry exploits women.
“Go back to Japan and watch how men interact with women.
Especially modern women, women around the world recognize
this,” he said.
In the United States, “we’re not living in the Flintstone
days,” he says. “In general, there is an awareness [by the
women] that there’s something better for me than what is
in my hometown.”
In fact, Krosky met his wife, a Filipina more than 18
years younger than he, through his own service. “She’s way
smarter then I am. She speaks six languages. I don’t try
to mold my wife. My wife is her own person. There’s no
molding or manipulation.”
Moreover, he says he thinks he is better suited for a
younger woman. “I’m youthful in appearance and healthy and
fit. When I look at women my age, they are not as
attractive to me.”
He’s been interested in Asian culture for many years, he
says. “When I was 12 or 13, I watched Kung Fu. Whenever I
saw Asian people it was interesting to me,” he said. “I
felt a connection to Asia. I’ve always had an interest.”
His interest expanded into attraction. “I’ve always been
attracted to Asian women. I like their manners.”
His wife, Hilanie, says she’s not bothered by the age
difference between her and her 42-year-old husband, with
whom she raises his son. She says she “likes an old
person, who knows about life is mature can share
experiences.”
She signed up for Cherry Blossoms while she was a student
at Saint Colunben College in the Philippines; most women
at her school did too, she adds.
“People knew it was good, decent, not like other
companies,” she explains. “You write letters and look at
how they write and their interests, about life, what kind
of woman they are looking for.”
Though she had had no boyfriends, she recalls, she was not
necessarily looking for romance, but rather “just for a
friend for correspondence.” After being introduced to her
husband-to-be, she wrote him three or four letters a week
for a year before they got married.
Mike was the first man she had met through such a service,
said his wife, though she added that he had had “met a
couple of women before me,” perhaps two to four Filipinas.
They didn’t work out, she said, “because he didn’t have
attraction to them at all. They had no chemistry.”
“American guys are good husbands compared to the
Philippines,” said Hilanie Krosky, who emphasized that her
preference for American men and her feelings for Mike in
particular were paramount in her decision.
“Most Filipino men are demanding. Most of the time they
are violent. They beat and hit you. For me, most of the
time Americans are good people, they care about women
compared to Filipino men. Besides, in the U.S., you can
not beat your wife. In the Philippines you can beat your
wife.
“It has nothing to do with citizenship. “If I met him and
I don’t have feelings toward him, I’m not going to get
married to him,” said Hilanie. She liked her husband,
“just because our chemistry to each other was there.”
Now a legal resident with a conditional visa, Hilanie is
looking forward to next year, when she hopes to apply for
citizenship. She says she does not plan to bring over
other kin. “My relatives don’t like to come to the U.S.,”
she explained. “My family lives a good life and has good
financial support in the Philippines.”
Both said they are happy. “I want to begin to dispel the
myths,” said Mike Krosky. “It’s not about mail-order
brides.
“Hello, this is a global world ... We are a global
population. We’re all connected.”
Janet Dang and Connie Hsiao contributed to this article.

|