Mail Order Brides: Pen Pals or
Prey?
By Matthew Fisher -
Toronto Sun: February 21, 1999
LOOKING FOR LOVE
Geraldine Lahaylahay and her cousin Leah Luyao were
forced to quit school for financial reasons and now work
as cooks in a streetside stall. CEBU, The Philippines --
Maridel Bacurnay may soon be winging her way to a new life
in Toronto.
The 26-year-old cashier has been corresponding by e-mail
with a 32-year-old Toronto accountant since last fall.
The man, whose identity Bacurnay would not reveal, is one
of six prospective husbands from Canada, Britain and the
United States that she has met over the Internet. While
unsure of which suitor to pick for a trip to the altar and
a ticket to the West, Bacurnay has narrowed her choice
down to the Canadian, an English farmer and an income tax
adviser from Boston.
I met Bacurnay through the Internet while researching what
the Philippine government and Philippine media call “mail-order brides.” I forked over $40US to retrieve
Bacurnay’s address and 20 others from a Web site devoted
to putting young women from Cebu in touch with lonely men
from cooler climes.
Women pay nothing to sign up with the many different
international electronic matchmaking services targeting
the Philippines. What they get in return for supplying
their addresses are letters from hundreds of Western men.
Some of these men, encouraged by what they have read and
the photographs they have received, pay $3,900 and more to
fly with organized tours to this island in the heart of
the Philippine archipelago to meet face to face with 15 or
20 would-be brides.
INTRODUCTIONS “I keep my tours small. I do quality introductions,”
boasted David Ryan of Asian Sun Tours, as he chain-smoked
in a hotel lobby moments before his own marriage to a
Filipina 20 years his junior.
Outraged by what is regarded as a modern-day trade in
human flesh, the Philippine government made it illegal
nine years ago to mention anything about Filipina women as
ideal brides or sex partners in newspaper advertisements
and pamphlets. Upon conviction, the penalty is
imprisonment for up to six years.
The murder of seven Filipinas who married “pen pals” from
Texas, Oregon and Australia, the use of photographs of
Filipinas seeking to meet men through a German erotic
magazine and the revelation that the wife of Oklahoma City
bombing accomplice Terry Nichols was a “mail-order bride,”
has only fuelled the debate.
Philippine Vice-President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo has
declared war on what she described as the “e-mail sex
trade.” But she has admitted that it has proven very
difficult to lay charges against companies based overseas
which use the Internet.
Like many Americans, Ryan first came to the Philippines
with the U.S. Navy. The New Jersey-based travel company he
founded is among several cited contemptuously by the
Philippine media as a mail-order business.
Ryan skirts the law by describing prospective brides as
pen pals. But his own brochure mentions immigration and
marriage repeatedly and the 46-year-old entrepreneur
claimed that between 300 and 400 of the meetings he has
arranged here for foreigners have led to marriages. “I know our government doesn’t like this. But I don’t
care,” said Bacurnay, who spoke with me in her office at
the United Coconut Planters Life Assurance Corporation. “We have our freedom and we choose for ourselves. There is
nothing that can be done to stop us from giving our names
to pen pal companies. I don’t think of this as a dirty
business. That’s a bad image to have. We’re not being
forced. This is what we want.”
Across town, in a small, mosquito-infested apartment that
is home to 15 cousins and lodgers, 21-year-old Noemi
Montes, was of the same opinion. “We’re scared about doing this. Maybe we will go to prison
just for talking about it,” the 21-year-old accounting
student said. “But how can the government control who we
marry?”
In an advertisement on the Internet, which prompted 90
responses, Montes described herself as “patient, loving,
understanding, romantic and definitely very affectionate.”
She said she hoped to have children and was seeking a man
older than 35 years of age from the U.S., Canada,
Australia or Europe. Her only specific request was that “he should know how to treat me well. That is all I ask.”
This bio and the accompanying photograph of the slim,
long-haired student were enough to get her on an airplane
to Australia where she met a divorced man almost exactly
twice her age. To prove that she had made the trip, she
volunteered photographs of herself in front of the Sydney
Opera House and at a backyard barbecue.
ROMANTIC
Noemi Montes, with her cousins, advertised herself as “patient, loving, understanding, romantic and very
affectionate.” “He’s not a bad guy, but I won’t marry him
because I found out that he knows many other women,”
Montes said. “While I was staying with him another
Filipina rang him. So, it’s his fault we didn’t marry, not
mine.”
Montes, who has nine brothers and sisters at home on the
island of Negros Occidental, said that as well as e-mail
correspondence she had received bags of letters since
giving her address out three years ago. Like Maridel
Bacurnay, she, now has a short list with a couple of names
on it. But she was angry about many of the letters she
received. “I don’t want any more pen pals. It’s too much trouble,”
Montes said as several young cousins played noisily around
her. “I can see in their faces that some of those who wrote to
me are bad men. They are lechers. They would ask me about
sex.”
David Ryan of Asian Sun Tours has sent the addresses of
the 800 Filipinas in his data base to “thousands and
thousands of men” in Canada and the U.S. Sorting the good
men from the bad wasn’t always easy, he admitted. “You get a lot of low life in this, especially from
newspaper ads. Some of them think it’s a piece of
furniture they’re ordering,” the lanky, jet-black-haired
American said. “Guys on the Internet are generally better
educated, but not all of them. One guy who sent me an
e-mail asked for nude photos.” “A lot of the operators in this business are real sleaze.
There aren’t too many decent ones.”
Among Ryan’s many rivals are Japanese, Korean and German
tour agencies. What Ryan had to say about them was mostly
unprintable.
Ryan claimed to be a cut above his foreign and American
competitors; however, some of the material in his own
brochure seemed to contradict this. “The Filipina woman is a truly traditional woman and that
is hard to find in the world today and almost impossible
to find in the U.S.,” the brochure said.
Filipinas were described as “extremely sensuous, but the
man’s looks and age, from our experience, do not seem to
be very important to them ... They actually seem to like
doing housework -- no kidding! These women are family
oriented, not to mention how ingrained it is in her
because of her culture, to please her husband.”
As for fears that the bride-to-be might fail American
medical checks, Ryan advised clients, “Remember,
gentlemen, these are fine, decent women and the majority
of them are virgins.”
None of this seemed to faze Michelle Dimol, a 28-year-old
accountant who helps co-ordinate Asian Sun Tours’
arrangements in Cebu and who is, herself, on the lookout
for a foreign husband.
MONEY FOR FAMILIES “I’m young, free and single and I want a white man because
they are so guapo (handsome),” Dimol said. “Many girls
have pen pals. It’s a good way to meet. Whether with mail
or e-mail, it is our only way to communicate. We don’t
have the money to travel and meet men.”
Dimol and other Filipinas receiving e-mails from would-be
paramours agreed that the main reason that women from the
Philippines wanted to marry foreigners was to get money to
help their families. “They can call us mail-order brides if they want, but it’s
a really good idea because it is practical,” said
Geraldine Lahaylahay, 19, who has read the dozens of
e-mails that her 19-year-old cousin, Leah Luyao, gets. “Our priority is to improve our financial situation and
this is the best way to do it,” Lahaylahay added.
Lahaylahay and Luyao were forced to quit school because
they could not pay annual tuition fees of about $600 a
year. They now make their living cooking food at a
streetside stall owned by their aunt, Colata Gonzalez.
They live with her and five female cousins in a rickety
two-room wooden house in a teeming slum a couple of
hundred metres from the provincial jail. “I’m all for it if they marry a foreigner,” said Gonzalez,
who is 42. “Lots of our neighbours have married
foreigners. I’d do it myself if I thought there was any
chance a foreigner would still find me attractive. “If they succeed, they will be missed. But they can come
back and visit and when they do they can bring presents
for the family.”
Asked if they thought Canadian women would ever marry a
Filipino man through the Internet, Gonzalez and her nieces
laughed for the longest time. “It’s all economic. There is always a crisis here. It
never ends,” Luyao said. “Even if some of the men who
write are bad, our lives can’t be worse than they are
here, so I’m not afraid.”
Despite her own circumstances, which were movingly
illustrated by her tumble-down residence in a particularly
rough part of town, Montes said she was not rejecting
Filipino men because they were poor. “I just don’t want a Filipino and that’s that,” she said. “They just don’t suit my taste. I feel my future is
overseas. I want to be in another country.”
Ryan said it would be wrong to blame Filipinas for
trying to improve their lot through marriage. “Let’s be honest, anyone with a choice will marry someone
richer rather than someone poorer,” he said. “These girls
are trying to marry Americans and Canadians because they
want a better life. They get great educations here and
then can’t get a job so they end up working for almost
nothing as nannies in Hong Kong.”
Ryan was certain that he knew why his clients wanted to
marry Filipinas. “Do you like Canadian women?” he asked. “I mean, let’s
face it, they have an attitude problem” without
elaborating. “Most of the girls I introduce are friends of friends or
cousins of friends of friends. The majority are of average
or a little above average looks. But some are stunning,
drop-dead gorgeous. “The guys? Well, not a lot of them look like Mr. America.
Not everything is in their favour, either. One hundred
guys may be writing one girl so she can choose the cream
of the crop. The girls take the best they can get and a
lot of the guys end up with Dear John letters or nothing
at all.”
While in Cebu for his marriage and honeymoon, Ryan was
also helping two men from the U.S. meet Filipinas. But all
was not going well.
Earl from Lexington, Massachusetts, a geeky-looking farmer
in his early 30s, was so upset by the chaos and poverty he
saw on the way from Manila to Cebu that he refused to meet
any of the women who wanted to meet him. Repelled and
homesick, his visit to the Philippines lasted 48 hours.
The first “date” of Previn, an Indian-born computer type
in his 30s who moved to the U.S. in his teens, was also a
disaster. He was so socially inept that he ordered dinner
for himself but did not know enough to do so for the
pretty 20-year-old woman he had invited, so she went
without anything to eat.
On his second date, which ended unhappily after a few
minutes, Previn was so paralyzed with fear that he was
virtually unable to speak.
Ryan was embarrassed, annoyed and greatly amused by the
bizarre antics of Earl and Previn. He insisted that he had
never before had such misfits for clients.
Maridel Bacurnay was obviously hoping for more. “I’ve made a folder for each one and keep their letters
and photos in it,” she said. “I haven’t chosen yet. I’m
still fixing my mind. I’m not so choosy. I just want
someone older than me.”
FINALIST FROM TORONTO
As for the Torontonian who is one of her finalists, she
said she kept his photo in a place of honour in her
bedroom. “He’s taller than me and has a nice body because he works
out once or twice a week. He’s like a big playful kid,”
she gushed of a man she has only spoken to once briefly on
the telephone. “He was upset because he had a girlfriend
before in Canada and it didn’t work out. He said he had
heard that Filipinas were of good character, so he tried
this.”
Maridel knew little about Canada, other than that it had
had a severe blizzard in January and has a stronger
economy than the Philippines. “Nothing about Canada bothers me because Filipinos call it
the gateway to the U.S. Once you’re there it is easier to
get into the States,” she said. “I know about the murders, but I feel that if it is your
time to die, you die. From what I can read from their
letters, the intentions of my suitors are good. “My plan is to marry a foreigner so that I can take care
of my family. My mother really, really wants me to go
abroad. She wants me to marry so that I can help my
brothers and sisters and so that she can join me there.
Her big idea is that we will one day go to Disneyland
together and meet Mickey Mouse.”
